Where Moral Authority Begins | Part VI: The Ohio River Valley, Holden Caulfield and the Seduction of False Prophets

Americans have always been drawn to figures of spiritual power. Revival preachers, family patriarchs, cultural icons, presidents. So often, we mistake confidence for capability, narcissism for strength, repetition for truth. The false prophet employs a performative brand of certainty that outlasts objective, empirical reality—the child who reports the abuse or the woman who saw it happen or the person who witnessed it and refuses to believe the lie doesn’t matter because everyone else has already agreed to accept the systemic ease of deception. The lie becomes the truth and they who wield it best become a sort of prophet, the moral authority, because the lie is the story that will come true, regardless.

The Catcher in the Rye celebrated its 75th birthday this year. I am curious about J. D. Salinger’s character, Holden Caulfield, a quintessential reflection of American infatuation with dishonesty: “I’m the most terrific liar you ever saw in your life. It’s awful.” What I also find curious are the ways that Salinger and my hometown Marietta, Ohio, intersect.

Like Holden, my life has been a search for moral clarity through the lies that began in Marietta. When I finally landed in Murray Hill, I thought Manhattan would be an entirely new chapter, an exclamation point leaving behind girlish origins and trading one version of America for another. What I found was quite the opposite. I found a connected origin story with many threads.

1970s Marietta was fishing on the river and Woolworths, where we sat at the soda counter with ice-cream floats. It was the Marietta Beer Barn, a funny little beer and soda store in a building made of concrete block with a giant cooler on one side and a drive-thru middle. The men took your money and filled your trunk with Budweiser and you never had to get out of your car. Marietta was summer afternoons walking over the bridge for a new pair of Levis at my Uncle’s Working Man’s Store. Marietta was also the Betsey Mills Club, where I learned to swim and plié from a one-time New York City ballerina who wielded a yard stick similar to Debbie Allen’s cane in Fame. The Betsey Mills was central to Marietta social life, a club devoted to young women transitioning from rural life to town living with rows of Victorian mansions along the river. The Victorian mansions were glorious, some built by the Ivy League magnates who established the city of Marietta, some by river boat captains. With all its small town grandeur, Marietta was most importantly family and church every Sunday, without fail, with Sunday dresses and Sunday hats and change to put in the offering plate. What I didn’t know, growing up, was Marietta’s dark past…. READ THE FULL ESSAY

Essay originally published at Eckleburg.

Johns Hopkins Conference on Craft, Bar Harbor, Maine, 2009

Rae Cline, author and Johns Hopkins M.A. in Writing candidate

This summer I begin the M.A. in Writing program at Johns Hopkins University. It is an on-campus program, with classes in Baltimore, Maryland; Washington, D.C.; and other campuses. My first workshop as a candidate is the Johns Hopkins Conference on Craft in Bar Harbor, Maine, held before my first fall semester. I’m excited that my graduate study in writing starts here, on the coast of Maine, in the land of lobster rolls and Stephen King. I’m a big fan of It. The scene when Georgie puts his hand into the shadow of the basement, feeling for the light switch, stays with me.

Bar Harbor and Stephen King’s Maine

King set It in Derry, his fictional version of Bangor, the Maine city where he lives, about an hour’s drive from Bar Harbor. He has said that Bangor became Derry, and the city’s old standpipe made its way into the novel.

Bar Harbor sits on Mount Desert Island, on Frenchman Bay, at the edge of Acadia National Park. It is a long way from the Ohio River.

Studying with Alice McDermott

The Conference on Craft is the program’s summer residency. For me it is a first look at the program, its faculty and the writers I will study with over the next two years, with workshop days and time to write.

My advisor for the conference is Alice McDermott, Johns Hopkins University’s Richard A. Macksey Professor of the Humanities. Her novel Charming Billy won the 1998 National Book Award for Fiction, and she has been a three-time finalist for the Pulitzer Prize, for That Night, At Weddings and Wakes and After This. To say that I am honored and excited to be working with McDermott is an understatement.

McDermott was born in Brooklyn, New York, in 1953 and studied at the State University of New York at Oswego and the University of New Hampshire. Her novels include A Bigamist’s Daughter, That Night, At Weddings and Wakes, Charming Billy, Child of My Heart and After This. She received a Whiting Writers’ Award in 1987 and the Corrington Award for Literature in 2008, and she has taught writing at American University, the University of New Hampshire and the University of California, San Diego.

Charming Billy opens with Billy Lynch’s family and friends gathered at a small Bronx bar after his funeral. Much of McDermott’s fiction stays with Irish-American families in New York, and with what those families remember and repeat about their own.

From the Ohio River Valley

I come to Johns Hopkins from the Ohio River Valley. I was born in Marietta, Ohio, and grew up there and in Reno and Rinard Mills, Ohio, and Williamstown, West Virginia. I am a first-generation college graduate. Much of what I write is set in that river country.

My first childhood home was a trailer. My father was an Army veteran, and my mother was a hair stylist who raised me in overalls, bare feet and sometimes ballet shoes. I spent many afternoons on the Ohio River, fishing from a skiff with my grandfather, and many more on the back porch, snapping green beans and making cornhusk dolls.

Rinard Mills and the Little Muskingum

Rinard Mills is a small village on the Little Muskingum River in Monroe County, Ohio, named for my fifth great-grandfather, Isaac Rinard. He was born in Pennsylvania in 1770 and apprenticed to a tanner at fifteen. He served under General Anthony Wayne in the war against the Native nations of the Ohio country, the war that pushed Native communities out of Ohio and opened the land to settlers like my ancestors, a dark and brutal moment in the country’s first days. Around 1830 Great Grandpa Rinard built a mill on the Little Muskingum, using the same flint millstones he had carried to two earlier mills. He died of blood poisoning in 1865 and is buried in the Rinard Mills Cemetery, where I buried my Grandma Ruthie. Great Grandpa Rinard’s story still turns up in local histories and in the pages of the Marietta Times.

The river has its own dark history. It floods, and it has taken the covered bridge downstream more than once. It is also beautiful. The Little Muskingum bends through the steep, wooded hills of the Wayne National Forest, past covered bridges, oil wells and Mail Pouch barns. Years ago a resident found the remains of a millstone in the river, and it was set into Great Grandpa Isaac’s grave marker.

My piece “Going Green” appears in the Summer 2009 issue of Literary Traveler, and my story “A History of Bloody Point, St. Christopher’s Island (1626)” won first place in the Whidbey Writers’ Student Choice Contest in 2008. You can find these and my other work on my publication archive.

On this site I will share news of my fiction and essays, publications and readings, and notes from the M.A. in Writing program as I work toward my degree. Thank you for visiting.

Rae Cline previously published as Rae Bryant.